Blinks: High quality reviews and training
Blinks: High quality reviews and training
Blinks: High quality reviews and training
High quality reviews and training
High quality reviews and training

Guest Column - January 2021
Malcolm Wheeler

Online passages from India

The pandemic will be remembered in the words of Dickens as "the worst of times" and, in the most unintended ways, also "the best of times". Before the lockdown, the challenge for our kind of schools was finding the sweet spot between theoretical and experiential learning. After the move to virtual learning, it has become about finding our collective 'ikigai', or finding our reason for being.

1. Mastering the virtual world
Just the other day I listened to a plaint: "It's November and my partner and I have not yet met!" No, it wasn't a bridegroom complaining about the delay in meeting his arranged match. It was one of our kindergarten teachers talking about how even though she has been working with her co-teacher in the same virtual classroom since August, they have still not met face to face. "And yet", she says, "We are in sync. with each other, our students and, our parents."

To start with, as a teacher of children, who primarily learn using all their senses and body, she was sceptical about the virtual world meeting the needs of 4 and 5 year olds. Six months into the lockdown she says it has had the most unintended consequence.

It has changed the equation between teachers and parents. "When we get sick our students' parents come into the room and give us virtual hugs", she beams, "And because they have been inside their children's classrooms, these parents are now following the same 'Essential Agreements' at home that we practise with our students inside the classroom."

I watch her and her partner teacher 'online', giving personal attention to each child, gauging the reading levels of every child, and celebrating the involvement of their parents as a valued partner who reads to their children and shares the joy of their enriched vocabulary.

2. Missing the physical connect
While our children are relishing the blended learning, from their home, almost all ache to get back to school so that they can be with their friends and interact with their teachers. There are many others for whom home is becoming somewhere in which they feel 'locked up'- their words, not mine.

And while they have access to co-curricular learning, I don't know a school leader who believes we are fully addressing the social, emotional, creative, psychological and, physical needs of our children 'locked out' of our schools. While as an instructional leader I am truly excited by what feels like a once in a career-defining opportunity to transform learning, I cannot ignore the human impact that Covid is having on our learning community.

Stress from long hours in front of a screen is evident in our teachers' voices. Over time it has taken a toll on the health with increased episodes of backache and headache. There is an absence of regular exercise which came from walking around the class and corridors and up and down the stairs. The line separating the personal and professional life is blurred and teachers are experiencing a constant restlessness.

3. A world with no boundaries
A friend said, "In this new world there are no boundaries. Work never ends for the day." That sentiment could just as easily have been expressed by a parent as they too try to juggle working from home, supporting their child's learning and psychological wellbeing, struggling to make up for the absence of stimuli for their kids and the whole family. The lack of boundaries is heightened by the inability to socially interact or ask for 'the village' to take over the upbringing of their child for a few hours at least.

The safety blanket that is offered to our students is largely only accessible to the more privileged learning communities.

As I watch our students discussing machine learning, astronomy and, aerodynamics, it becomes painfully clear that there is a paradoxical chasm between their learning during COVID, and that of students who do not even have a device or a telephone signal and have suddenly been at liberty to spend time with their friends and family as apprentices in workshops and fields. Two different kinds of experiential learning. Which would our children choose if they could?

4. Blended learning accessible to all
For many children across the nation, the worst is that there is little or no access to schooling, whether physical or virtual, and where it does exist, too often it is examination year focused. As a result, many students in rural areas have revelled in the opportunities given to them to play, explore, roam the countryside and help their parents.

Suddenly, the world has become their experiential learning community, maybe richer than the text focused classroom. I wonder if the online "experiential" learning community such as ours can appreciate and aspire to embracing the rich, engaged collaborative learning that may not be founded on enquiry, but finds the joy of learning in the real world much like Twain's Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn!

Then I read the world bank report warning of learning loss and I wonder what it means for those who have worked so hard to come out of poverty only to be pushed back in because their children aren't 'digital natives' and so once again have an unequal playing field.

Malcolm Wheeler is Director, Heritage Xperiential Learning School, Gurgaon, India

Online passages from India (January 2021)

Guest Column – December 2020
Keith Grainger, Principal, Garth Hill College
The case for the defence: online learning
In a week when the government has threatened councils with legal action over decisions to switch to online learning over coronavirus fears, I feel the urge to celebrate the considerable merits of online learning. Such threats almost cast a slur on the very concept of online learning and, given our positive experience as a state secondary school, I am compelled to make a case for the defence.
The case for the defence: online learning (December 2020)     © Blinks 2021

Data privacy & security             Website by Relaxed